The short answer

A marketing audit on your own business comes down to three numbers: leads per month by channel, cost per lead, and lead-to-customer conversion rate. Find those three, score your marketing across five layers, and you know exactly what to fix first. No $5K analytics setup, about 60 minutes.

  • The 3 numbers: leads per month by channel, cost per lead, and lead-to-customer conversion rate. Everything else is noise.
  • The 5 layers: traffic and visibility, website and conversion, lead capture, email and nurture, and strategy and measurement. Each scores out of 10, for 50 total.
  • The problem: 73% of business owners don’t know if their marketing is working. Only 18% feel “very confident,” down from 27% last year.
  • Track enquiries and the 3 numbers, not impressions or likes. Run the audit quarterly.
Short on time to do this yourself? This is the exact work I set up for service businesses, done for you, and the system is yours to keep.

Get me to do it →

73% of business owners don’t know if their marketing is actually working. That’s not a guess, that’s from a survey of 2,500 small businesses. And honestly? I’m surprised it’s not higher. Because when I ask business owners “what’s your cost per lead?”, most can’t answer. When I ask “which channel generates the most enquiries?”, blank stares. This audit fixes that.

The Only 3 Numbers Your Marketing Audit Needs

Let me ask you something. Right now, without looking anything up:

  • How many leads did your marketing generate last month?
  • What was your cost per lead?
  • What percentage of those leads became paying customers?

If you can’t answer all three, you’re not alone. Most business owners can’t. And that’s not because they’re bad at marketing, it’s because nobody ever showed them which numbers actually matter.

#1
Leads per month, by channel
#2
Cost per lead
#3
Lead to customer conversion rate

That’s it. Not 20 metrics. Not a dashboard with 50 KPIs. Three numbers.

When the business I worked at grew four times over, these were the only 3 I tracked. Everything else, impressions, clicks, engagement, follower counts, was noise. Those metrics make you feel good. These 3 make you money.

73% of business owners don’t know if their marketing is working. Only 18% feel “very confident,” down from 27% last year. Meanwhile, marketing budgets went up 37%. More spending, less confidence. That’s not a strategy. That’s a crisis. The 5 layers below feed those 3 numbers.
How this audit works. Below are 5 layers. For each, count the statements that are true for your business right now. Be honest, the gaps are the point. Each layer scores out of 10, for 50 total. When you’ve worked through all 5, you’ll know your weakest layer and exactly what to fix first.

The 5 Layers Behind the 3 Numbers

1Layer 1: Traffic & Visibility.

Are people actually finding you? Open Google Analytics, Acquisition, then Traffic Acquisition (last 30 days), and your Google Business Profile, then Performance.

  • Consistent, growing traffic from at least one channel: organic search, paid ads, or local SEO. (3 pts)
  • A claimed and fully optimised Google Business Profile. (2 pts)
  • 20+ Google reviews with a 4.5+ star average. (2 pts)
  • You know which channel drives the most visitors to your website. (2 pts)
  • Your website traffic has grown compared to 3 months ago. (1 pt)

What this tells you: if 80%+ of your traffic is “Direct” you’re relying on word of mouth. That works until it doesn’t. When I was running marketing at the business I ran marketing for, Google Ads and local SEO together drove 70%+ of new enquiries. Word of mouth was the bonus, not the strategy.

2Layer 2: Website & Conversion.

Is your website turning visitors into enquiries, or just looking pretty? Open your homepage in an incognito window and answer honestly.

  • Within 5 seconds, a stranger can tell what my business does and who it’s for. (2 pts)
  • There’s ONE clear call to action visible without scrolling. (2 pts)
  • There’s social proof visible on the homepage: reviews, testimonials, client logos. (2 pts)
  • My website loads in under 3 seconds on mobile (test at pagespeed.web.dev). (2 pts)
  • My homepage bounce rate is under 60%. (2 pts)

The $10K website trap: I’ve seen $10K–$25K websites with beautiful design and zero lead capture. That’s a brochure, not a marketing tool. If your website doesn’t convert visitors into enquiries, it doesn’t matter how much you spend on ads. You’re pouring water into a bucket with holes.

3Layer 3: Lead Capture.

97% of visitors won’t buy on their first visit. If you don’t capture their email, they’re gone. A lead magnet, a PDF, checklist, or calculator that solves one problem, is the bridge.

  • I have at least one lead magnet or opt-in offer (not just “subscribe to our newsletter”). (3 pts)
  • The opt-in is visible on my homepage without scrolling. (2 pts)
  • I gained new email subscribers in the last 30 days. (3 pts)
  • I know my current email list size. (2 pts)

What actually works: at the business I ran marketing for, our lead magnet was a buyer’s comparison guide, an 8-page PDF answering the customer’s #1 question before they were ready to buy. It generated thousands of downloads over 2 years. The lesson: solve one specific problem your customer has before they’re ready to buy.

4Layer 4: Email & Nurture.

Email returns $36–$42 for every $1 spent, highest ROI of any channel. Yet most businesses either don’t use it or send one blast every few months.

  • I have an automated welcome email or sequence that triggers when someone opts in. (3 pts)
  • I send at least one email per month to my list. (2 pts)
  • My email open rate is above 20%. (2 pts)
  • I’ve sent an email to my list in the last 30 days. (2 pts)
  • I track open rates and click rates for my emails. (1 pt)

5Layer 5: Strategy & Measurement.

This is where it all comes together. Remember the 3 numbers from the start? This layer is about whether you can actually answer them.

  • I have a written marketing plan, even a one-pager. (2 pts)
  • I know my cost per lead. (2 pts)
  • I know my lead-to-customer conversion rate. (2 pts)
  • I review marketing performance at least monthly. (2 pts)
  • I can name my #1 marketing channel right now. (2 pts)

What not to track: ignore impressions, social media likes, and engagement rates. You can have 10 million impressions and zero revenue. If your agency reports on impressions instead of leads, cost per lead, and conversion, that tells you everything you need to know.

Use AI to do it

Run the marketing audit with Claude in 10 minutes

You don’t have to work the maths by hand. Pull your last 30 days of numbers, then paste them into Claude (free) with this:

I run a [your business] in [your area]. I’m auditing my own marketing.
Here are my numbers for the last 30 days: [paste leads by channel,
total marketing spend, and how many leads became paying customers].
Work out my three core numbers: leads per month by channel, cost per
lead, and lead-to-customer conversion rate. Then score me out of 10 on
each of five layers (traffic, website, lead capture, email, strategy),
name my weakest layer, and give me the single first fix that will move
cost per lead or conversion the most.

That turns a pile of raw numbers into your three metrics, a layer score, and a first action, without a $5K analytics setup.

The Bottom Line

If you couldn’t tell me your cost per lead before reading this, now you know exactly where to find it. You know which of your 5 layers is weakest and what to fix first.

That’s the entire point. Not to overwhelm you with tactics. Not to sell you services. Just to give you the 3 numbers that matter and the clarity to act on them. Your marketing isn’t broken. Your visibility was. Now it’s not.

Run this audit quarterly. Check your 3 numbers weekly, it takes 5 minutes once you know where to look. And every time you’re about to spend money on marketing, ask yourself: which layer am I improving, and which of my 3 numbers should move as a result?

If you can answer that, you’re ahead of 73% of business owners. And nobody can bullshit you.

Straight answers (FAQ)

A marketing audit is a structured check of whether your marketing actually generates leads and customers. This one scores five layers (traffic, website, lead capture, email, and strategy) against the three numbers that matter: leads per month, cost per lead, and lead-to-customer conversion rate.

Leads per month by channel, cost per lead, and the percentage of leads that become paying customers. Not 20 metrics, not a 50-KPI dashboard. Impressions, clicks and follower counts make you feel good. These three make you money.

About 60 minutes to work through all five layers honestly. After that, checking your three core numbers takes about 5 minutes a week once you know where to look. Run the full audit quarterly.

No. You don’t need a $5K analytics setup. Google Analytics (Acquisition, then Traffic Acquisition), your Google Business Profile Performance tab, pagespeed.web.dev, and your email platform’s open rates cover it.

Your weakest layer. Score each of the five layers out of 10. The lowest score is where a fix moves your numbers the most. If you can’t yet state your cost per lead or conversion rate, start with Layer 5, Strategy and Measurement.

Sources: figures as cited in the small business marketing data referenced in this audit, including a confidence survey of 2,500 small businesses and published email ROI benchmarks. Quoted as stated.

Free · 60 Seconds

Not sure where your marketing is leaking?

The free Lead Machine Scorecard checks your traffic, website, lead capture, email and strategy, and tells you exactly what to fix first. Same 5-layer framework, with a personalised action plan.

Take the Free Scorecard →

Happy to run it yourself? Everything above is the system, use it. Rather have the whole thing installed and owned by you? That’s what I do →

Get in touch

Prefer to talk it through? Call or text, email, or send a message.

Ty Pryor, small business marketing strategist

Ty Pryor
Small business marketing strategist. The only marketing hire inside a business that grew four times over. The local SEO system in this post is the one that drove 700+ showroom visits a year at zero ad spend.