The short answer

The headline formula that sells for a trade business is: we help [X] achieve [Y] by [Z]. X is a specific buyer, Y is the outcome they actually want, and Z is the mechanism that makes it believable. Z is the part most trades leave out, and it is the part that does the selling.

  • David Ogilvy found that, on average, five times as many people read the headline as read the body copy.
  • Specific beats clever. Ogilvy, John Caples and Claude Hopkins all found it, decades apart.
  • Your headline should call out the buyer, promise their outcome, and prove it with how you do it.
  • The free headline generator writes three versions from five questions.
Short on time to do this yourself? This is the exact work I set up for service businesses, done for you, and the system is yours to keep.

Get me to do it →

The headline formula I use for every trades client is one sentence long: we help [X] achieve [Y] by [Z]. It is not mine. It is a compressed version of what the best advertisers of the last hundred years kept finding when they tested headlines against each other.

Why does the headline matter so much?

Because most people only read the headline. David Ogilvy wrote that, on the average, five times as many people read the headline as read the body copy. In Ogilvy on Advertising (1983) he followed it with the uncomfortable bit: if your headline doesn’t sell, you have wasted 90 per cent of your money.

Twenty years earlier, in Confessions of an Advertising Man, he put it as money: when you have written your headline, you have spent eighty cents out of your dollar. People often quote that as “spend 80 cents of every dollar on the headline”. That is not quite what he said, but the point holds. The headline carries most of the weight.

Eugene Schwartz, in Breakthrough Advertising (1966), was blunter still. He wrote that your headline has one job: stop your prospect and get them to read the next sentence. On a phone, that means stopping the thumb.

5x
more people read the headline than the body copy (Ogilvy, 1983)
5–10x
more responses from changing the headline, in Claude Hopkins’ tested ads (1923)
35%
of links users could not identify from the first 11 characters (NN/g, 2009)

That last number matters on a phone. Nielsen Norman Group showed people only the first 11 characters of links and found that for 35 per cent of them, users had no idea where they led. Plain, specific words up front were understood. Vague openers like “Introducing” were not. That study was about web links, but I see the same thing on mobile ads: your first few words are most of what gets read.

What is the headline formula?

The headline formula is we help [X] achieve [Y] by [Z], and each letter answers a question the buyer is silently asking.

XWho is this for? (a specific buyer)

Not “homeowners”. Homeowners renovating a kitchen on a budget. Builders working to tight handover dates. The tighter X is, the more the reader feels it was written for them. Claude Hopkins said the purpose of a headline is to pick out the people you can interest, the way calling “Hey there, Bill Jones” turns one head in a crowd.
YWhat do they get? (the dream outcome)

The result they would describe to a mate over a beer. The first point Ogilvy made about headlines was to promise the reader a benefit. Schwartz added that copy cannot create desire, it can only channel desire that already exists. So Y has to be something your buyer already wants, in their words, not yours.
ZWhy should they believe you? (the mechanism)

This is the bit most trades skip. Z is how you deliver Y, stated plainly enough to be believable. “Quality workmanship” is not a mechanism. “We template and cut every benchtop in-house” is. Ogilvy summarised John Caples’ testing this way: specifics are more believable than generalities.

Alex Hormozi’s value equation explains why Z does so much work. In $100M Offers he says value goes up with the dream outcome and the buyer’s perceived likelihood of achieving it, and down with time delay and effort. Y is the dream outcome. Z is the perceived likelihood. A headline with no Z is asking the reader to take your word for it, and nobody does.

Free tool
Want yours written for you? Answer five questions about your trade and the headline generator gives you three versions built on this formula, ready to copy onto your site or your ads.
Generate my headlines →

What does the headline formula look like in practice?

Here is the real example I talk about most. A cabinet maker sold flat-pack kitchens. The kitchens were genuinely premium, and they wanted to look premium without scaring off people on a budget. The headline:

We help homeowners get custom kitchens at flat-pack prices by cutting out the showroom and selling direct.

X is homeowners. Y is a custom kitchen at a flat-pack price. Z is no showroom and selling direct, which is the reason the price is possible. Premium for less is the tension that stops the scroll, and the missing showroom is the reason to believe it.

The ad sent traffic to a landing page that repeated the headline word for word. Everything underneath existed to back it up: reviews, testimonials, good photos of finished kitchens, and copy explaining exactly how removing the showroom keeps the price down.

Headline examples: generic vs formula

Trade Generic (what most sites say) Formula (X, Y and Z)
Stonemason Quality stone benchtops, no job too big or small. We help builders hit handover on time by templating and cutting every benchtop in-house.
Cabinet maker Custom kitchens built with passion and precision. We help homeowners get custom kitchens at flat-pack prices by cutting out the showroom and selling direct.
Builder Your trusted local builder for over 20 years. We help first-home buyers build on budget by locking every selection before we start.

The generic column could belong to any business in any town. Swap the logo and nobody would notice. The formula column could only belong to one.

How do you write your own headline with the formula?

Answer these four honestly, pick your main angle (price, speed or quality), then cut every word that does not earn its place. Same questions the generator asks.

1Name the buyer you most want more of

Pick one. If you do both builders and homeowners, write a headline for each. Ogilvy recommended putting a word in the headline that flags the reader you are after, and putting the city name in for local businesses.
2Write the outcome in their words

Write it the way they would say it. “A benchtop that’s the first thing guests notice.” “Move in without the budget blowing out.” Read your last five reviews. Your customers have already written Y for you.
3Find your real mechanism

What do you do that most of your competitors don’t or won’t? In-house fabrication. Fixed-price contracts. One project manager start to finish. Showing the client their exact slab before cutting. If you cannot name one, that is a business problem, not a copywriting problem, and no headline will fix it.
4Write what you are against

What does your competition do that you would never do? Quoting low then hitting you with variations. Disappearing mid-job. Swapping in a cheaper slab. The best headlines often come from this answer, because buyers already resent it. “No low-ball base price. No surprise variations.” works because it names something they have been burned by.
More from the playbook

Once the headline is right, the copy under it has to back it up. Read the website copywriting guide →

Is shorter always better for a headline?

No. Shorter is better only when nothing is lost. Ogilvy’s own data was mixed: some research showed long headlines selling more, other research showed fewer people reading them. His foreword to Caples’ Tested Advertising Methods settles it well enough: long headlines that say something are more effective than short headlines that say nothing. Caples himself said to state the complete thought even if it takes 20 words.

For trades, I aim for 15 words or fewer, because most of your traffic is on a phone and the first few words do the heavy lifting. But I would take a 15-word headline with a real Z over a five-word slogan every time. “Built different” says nothing. “We template and cut in-house, so your benchtop doesn’t hold up handover” says something.

What do Hormozi and Kennedy add to the formula?

Hormozi’s advice on ads in $100M Leads starts with the callout: get the right person’s attention before anything else. His favourite local version is local area plus type of person, for example “Geelong homeowners renovating a kitchen”. That is X with a postcode on it. He calls the headline the first sale, and says his advertising became around 20 times more effective once he put most of his effort into the first five seconds. That is his own account, not a controlled test, but it lines up with what Ogilvy and Caples found about headlines.

Dan Kennedy gets there through the flag. In The Ultimate Sales Letter he teaches headlines like “For busy doctors: how to…” which do the same job as X: tell the right reader, in the first few words, that this is for them. Kennedy is also big on the unique selling proposition, the reason to choose you over every other option, and that reason is your Z.

Where the formula comes from. I could not find a single person who invented “we help X achieve Y by Z”, and I would rather say so than make one up. It is a positioning statement, a cousin of Geoffrey Moore’s “for [target] who [need]” template from Crossing the Chasm, and of the CV formula Laszlo Bock shared while running people at Google: accomplished X, as measured by Y, by doing Z. The headline research above is why it works.
Use AI to do it

Write your headline with Claude

If you would rather do it in Claude than the generator, paste this in and fill in the brackets. The rule about not inventing facts matters: AI loves to add “7-day turnaround” when you never said it.

Write three website headlines for my trade business using the formula “we help [X] achieve [Y] by [Z]”.
My buyer (X): [who you serve, be specific]
Their dream outcome (Y): [in their words]
What I do differently (Z): [your mechanism]
What I would never do: [what competitors do that you refuse to]
Rules:
– Each headline 15 words or fewer, Australian spelling.
– One straight formula headline, one built from what I am against, one leading with price, speed or quality.
– Never invent facts I did not give you: no timeframes, prices, guarantees, years in business or review counts.
– No “quality workmanship”, “no job too big or small”, “passionate” or “one-stop shop”.
– Under each, one sentence on why it works.

Where should the headline go once you have it?

Put it in three places, word for word: the top of your homepage, the first line of your Facebook or Instagram ad, and the top of the landing page that ad points to. When the ad and the page say the same thing, the visitor knows they are in the right place. When they don’t, they leave.

Then build everything under the headline to prove it. If Z is “in-house fabrication”, show the workshop. If Y is “on budget”, show a review from someone whose budget held. The headline gets the read. The proof gets the call.

Your headline is working if
  • A stranger could tell what you do and who it is for in five seconds
  • It names a buyer, an outcome and a reason to believe
  • A competitor could not put it on their site without lying
Rewrite it if
  • It could belong to any business in your trade
  • It leans on “quality”, “trusted” or “passionate”
  • It is your business name and nothing else

The honest summary

A better headline will not fix a bad offer, slow replies or a page with no reviews. What it will do is get more of the right people to read the next line, which is the only job it has. Get X specific, write Y in their words, and make Z something you can prove. If you only change one line on your website this month, change this one.

Straight answers (FAQ)

Use “we help [X] achieve [Y] by [Z]”. X is a specific buyer, Y is the outcome they want in their own words, and Z is the mechanism that makes it believable, such as in-house fabrication or fixed-price contracts. The mechanism is what separates it from every other trades website.

Close, but not quite. In Confessions of an Advertising Man (1963) Ogilvy wrote that when you have written your headline, you have spent eighty cents out of your dollar. In Ogilvy on Advertising (1983) he wrote that on average five times as many people read the headline as the body copy.

Long enough to name the buyer, the outcome and the reason to believe you. Ogilvy and Caples both found long headlines that say something beat short ones that say nothing. For trades traffic that is mostly on phones, 15 words or fewer is a good target.

Avoid phrases every competitor uses: quality workmanship, no job too big or small, family owned and operated, one-stop shop, second to none and passionate. They make no specific claim, so the reader learns nothing and believes nothing. Replace them with what you actually do differently.

Yes. The free headline generator at typryor.com/headline asks about your buyer, their outcome, your edge, what you refuse to do and your main angle, then writes three headlines on the X, Y, Z formula. It is free and needs no sign-up.

Sources: David Ogilvy, Ogilvy on Advertising (1983), chapter 7, and Confessions of an Advertising Man (1963); John Caples, Tested Advertising Methods (5th ed., 1997), including Ogilvy’s foreword to the 4th edition; Claude Hopkins, Scientific Advertising (1923); Eugene Schwartz, Breakthrough Advertising (1966), chapters 1 and 2; Geoffrey Moore, Crossing the Chasm (1991); Laszlo Bock, “My Personal Formula for a Winning Resume” (LinkedIn, 2014); Alex Hormozi, $100M Offers (2021) and $100M Leads (2023); Dan Kennedy, The Ultimate Sales Letter (3rd ed., 2006); Nielsen Norman Group, First 2 Words (2009).

Free · 15 questions

Find out where your marketing is leaking.

The free scorecard checks your traffic, website, lead capture, email and strategy, and tells you exactly what to fix first.

Take the Free Scorecard →

Happy to write it yourself? Everything above is the real playbook. Use it. If you’d rather stay on the tools and have the whole lead machine installed and owned by you, that’s what I do →

Get in touch

Prefer to talk it through? Call or text, email, or send a message.

Ty Pryor

Ty Pryor
Small business marketing & AI. I build lead systems for trades and share the workflows I actually run. No hype, no fluff.